Arts and Sciences Curriculum Committee
February 12, 2013
3:30 in BCC 203
 
DRAFT MINUTES

Recording Secretary K. Nantz

Members present: Anita Fernandez, Johanna Garvey, Manual Im, Jerelyn Johnson, Kathy Nantz (recording secretary), Doug Peduti, Vin Rosicach (chair), Giovanni Ruffini, Tommy Xie.

New course proposals were considered as follows

1.     PO 135: Global Governance: International Law and Organizations
JJ moved to approve/MI seconded.
VR Ð This is a new faculty member and a new courses for her.  MI Ð looks like a much needed course.
7 in favor/1 abstention.

2.    PO 136: Threats to Global Security in the 21st Century

MI moved to approve/DP seconded.
MI Ð This looks like a good course for both programs, IL and politics.
Unanimous.

3.    MA/CS 151: Functional Programming

JJ moved to approve/GR seconded.
JJ Ð This proposal is modifying and replacing existing course.  It looks like the department has done its due-diligence and carefully considered the course.
Unanimous.

4.    MA 120-221: Applied Calculus II and III

KN moved to approve/AF seconded.
Unanimous.
MI moved/TX seconded.
There were questions about the numbering and use of 221 in this new sequence.  Why is it only for minors?  It seems to catch students who take the lower level (119/122) calculus sequence, and need the more rigorous third course to finish the material on integration. 
KN -- When the Math Department proposes changes to the minor to include these new courses, the ASCC needs to be sure that the course requirements are clear to all students, particularly given the different levels of calculus that exist.
Unanimous.

5.    RS 240: The Medieval Church

GR moved to approve/DP seconded. 
GR Ð This is a fantastic field for the Religious Studies Department to begin to offer.  They already offer lots of courses about Early Christianity and about modern religions but the medieval church is important to understanding these other time periods.  The course is a great addition to departmental offerings.  DP Ð The department seems very enthusiastic about the courses, and it will be useful to the Catholic Studies program as well. 
Unanimous.

6.    RS 276: Islamic Theology

JJ moved to approve/TX seconded.
JJ Ð This sounds like a good course and the Religious Studies department clearly supports it.
Unanimous.

7.    CO 547: Health Care Organizational Communication

KN moved to approve/MI seconded.
GR Ð Raised questions regarding the format of the course as a hybrid.  It is designed as a seven week course along with a hybrid component.  MI -- Responded that the expectation is that the course is equally as rigorous as a complete face-to-face experience.  There are a number of courses already being taught as hybrids at Fairfield.
GR Ð Does not believe that online interaction is equivalent to in-class time.  He is ok with the accelerated format but not with the online component.  He has never voted to approve an online course.
Im Ð Informed the committee that there is a proposal in the CAS DeanÕs office to make online courses at FU more consistently rigorous.  The initiative is in the planning phases, headed for the faculty committee process in the near future.
KN Ð Asked a question regarding student learning outcomes; in this syllabus there are goals but no listing of student learning outcomes.  VR responded that the committee typically takes either goals or learning outcomes, but sometimes makes recommendations to authors about how to improve this section of their syllabi.
MI Ð Suggested that we might take some issues that arise from our deliberations to the CAS for discussion and debate. Some of these might include, 1) more consistent requirements for online and hybrid courses, and 2) requirement that both student learning outcomes and course goals be included on new course proposals.
Approved: 9 in favor, 1 opposed.

8.    FTM 220: Intermediate Screenwriting
JG moved to approve/AF seconded.
MI Ð This is a much needed course for the majors in this department.  There is a beginning screen writing course and then students move onto major projects and writing.  This is a good addition to the program as it will provide students with needed development of their skills before they do independent work.  DP Ð The grade letter distribution is not in accordance with FU policy, there is no D- listed there.  This needs to be brought into line with the catalog.
JJ Ð Are these courses ever cross-listed with English?  MI Ð The MFA program might be interested in offering screenwriting courses to their students.  TX Ð The Creative Writing Program in English is expanding now, so cross-listing could be a possibility in the future.
Unanimous.

9.    FTM 132: Web Design

AF moved to approve/GR seconded.
DP Ð The catalog description is too long, it exceeds the 100-word maximum.  MI Ð Asked questions about staffing of this FTM course?  None of the full-time faculty have web design expertise.  The course will, given current staffing, always be handled by adjuncts.  He sees staffing as a real issue, and hesitates to approve a course for the catalog that is waiting for someone to staff.  GR Ð There is no real departmental response to question 9B on the new course proposal form.  He further asked about FTM 10, why is it a prerequisite?  What elements of that course are required for FTM 132? 
VR Ð Suggested that the committee might vote to approve pending answers to some questions --  why is FTM 10 a prerequisite, and how is the department planning for staffing the course?
MI Ð Made a motion to table consideration of FTM 132 pending answers to questions about prerequisite and staffing.  (GR second)
Unanimous.

10.    FTM 102: American History Television and Analysis
MI Ð Motion to table, citing the same issues that arose in FRM 132 discussion above. 
Unanimous.

11.    FTM 107:  TV Genres
JG moved to approve/TX seconded.
JJ Ð Asked if there is a full-time faculty member on staff now to teach this course, particularly since the department plans to offer it every semester.  MI Ð Replied yes.  The department now offers one sort of genre course every semester, but not TV every semester.  Staffing issues are also a problem again with FTM 107.   JJ Ð In the departmental minutes, it is unclear how frequently the course will be taught.  VR Ð Suggested that the committee has to take the department at their word that staffing is possible.  GR Ð The committee should ask for a change in the proposal to indicate more clarity in the plan for course rotations.  
MI Ð Replied that full-time faculty currently on staff can teach this course, even though the syllabus presented in this proposal was constructed by a part-time person.  JG Ð Noted that this proposal was presented to the committee by the FTM department rather than by an individual faculty member.  The attached syllabus is by a part-timer, but ÒProposed byÓ should be a person, not a program or department.  The proposal should indicate an individual full-time faculty contact. 
VR Ð Suggested asking the department for the following clarifications:  1) resubmit the proposal by a single full-time faculty member, not the department as a collective, and 2) submit a sample projected rotation to clarify staffing issue (i.e., what question 9B on the proposal form requests). JJ Ð Is also confused about how genres will rotate by semester.  Can the student take the same course (with different genres emphasized) more than once?
GR Ð Made a motion to table FTM 107 pending answers to questions about responsible faculty and staffing.  (JJ seconds.) 
Approved: 7 in favor/1 abstention.

12.    FTM 109: Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity, and the Movies
JG Ð Made a motion to table FTM 107, raising the same issues described above.  (IM seconds)
Unanimous.

13.    EN 130: Literature by Women: Vision and Revision
JG moved to approve/TX seconded.
KN Ð Asked JG about the fit with other lit courses focused on women writers.  JG Ð replied that this course is part of the departmentÕs 100-level course redesign, and complements nicely other upper-level offerings.
Unanimous.

14.    CL 302: Athenian Democracy and Empire / HI 302
AF moved to approve/JG seconded.
KN Ð Asked a question about the presentations required of students, will these be every week for every students or less frequently?  This is not clear from the proposal.  GR Ð Clarified that students would have a single large presentation each semester.   JJ Ð Asked about question 9b for both Classical Studies and for the History Department.  How often will this be taught and how does this fit with other departmental offerings?  GR Ð This is a new 300-level offering for him in the History Department.  It will now fit into his regular rotation for History 300-level courses.  He is swapping it out for another course that is being let go to sunset.  MI Ð Requested an answer to 9b from the History Department, noting that the committee already has this information for Classical Studies.
Unanimous approval pending information forwarded from History to the committee.

Other Business
*Theatre Curriculum Redesign Ð Guest Marti LoMonaco joined the committee to answer questions about the redesign.  This is a Theater Department curriculum revision.  It has been simplified from the existing curriculum that was designed based on the departmentÕs hope for lots of theater majors.  With fewer students in the program, the tracks are not useful.  The department focusses on theater as a liberal art and wants to provide broader training for all students than tracks allow .  The theory will be presented in the classroom while the practice will happen with student participation in Theater Fairfield.  The program has been streamlined and it is easier for every student to complete the requirements in in 4 years.  There is evidence from conversations with alumni that the more comprehensive background is more productive for students.
MI Ð Could someone go through the major and only take 4 upper-division courses in the major out of the 11 courses required for completion?  ML Ð most majors take more than that, but only 4 required.  MI Ð concern that could be not enough depth.  ML Ð Responded that her courses provide depth regardless of their number and that therefore students get all the depth required.  It is hard to fill higher level courses without more students.
KN Ð In the capstone production theory course, are minors and majors in same section?  ML -- Minors need the experience offered by the capstone, students donÕt get those experiences in other departmental courses.
AF Ð Does this new curriculum follow best practices in other theater departments?  ML Ð Yes.
JJ Ð DonÕt students need 200-level courses to get to capstone?  ML -- No, but many do bring this background to the course.
The committee thanked Professor LoMonaco.
GR made the motion to approve/DP seconded.
MI Ð Is concerned about the possibility that a major could take all lower-level courses and miss the depth that a major curriculum should provide.  VR Ð Other departments have designed similar curricula, with many lower-level courses and few (if any) upper-level offerings.  It is easier to get students into courses if there are fewer prerequisites.  GR Ð What, then, do numerical categories for courses mean if some departments do not follow the numbering convention?  VR Ð Individual departments seem to follow their own norms.  UCC might take up a proposal to encourage departments to reconsider both the breadth and depth of their curricula.
JG Ð What is the status of all of the courses listed in the proposal as new courses?  VR Ð The are not yet on the books.  He will indicate that new courses listed in the proposal will need to be reviewed by the committee as they are developed and revised, even the course being split down the middle.  JG Ð ShouldnÕt we have all of these courses before approving the curriculum redesign?  VR Ð The department may want to have this framework in place before they write up all of the new courses.  The redesign cannot be implemented until the required courses are approved. 
The Theater Department major was approved with a note that 100-level courses and all required new courses must be approved by the ASCC before they are offered. 
Unanimous.

*Music Minor Redesign

TX made a motion to approve/MI seconded.
MI Ð Noted that the music education minor is separate from this proposal and would continue to exist as a separate offering..
Unanimous.

DP moved to adjourn/seconded by MI.



Respectfully submitted,

Kathryn Nantz